Another football signing day has come and gone, and left in its wake are a load of CSU fans wondering why new coach Jim McElwain didn't bring in a class of studs to rival that of Alabama, where he served as offensive coordinator prior to coming to Fort Collins.
They point to Rivals.com, the popular (and polarizing) website dedicated to sating the appettites of knowledge-hungry football fans, which has Coach Mac's first recruiting class ranked 10th -- dead last -- in the Mountain West. Some of them are convinced that CSU, thanks to this ranking, is doomed to fail both now and in the future.
Having covered more than 20 signing days, I long ago realized that recruiting websites like Rivals -- to put it politely -- don't know squat. Sure, many of their "5-star, can't-miss" prospects become collegiate stars and go on to NFL careers, but a large number of them are complete flops, too.
Remember Marcus Houston, the former CSU running back? He was considered the very best high school running back in the country while starring at Denver's Thomas Jefferson High School, and it was a huge deal when he signed with CU. But he never fit in with the Buffs, and ended up transferring to CSU. His Ram career was one of utter mediocrity and, quite frankly, most CSU fans remember him for a fumble that cost the Rams a victory over Utah rather than anything good. Nice kid. Bad football player.
So much for five stars.
Because of Houston and others like him, I never get too caught up in rankings of players or recruiting classes. Sure, it would be nice if McElwain and his staff had been able to land a bunch of blue-chip studs coveted by every Top 10 school, but that was unrealistic. Coach Mac got a late start on the recruiting game because of his commitment to Alabama's appearance in the national championship game, and most of the nation's top-ranked players had long since pledged their loyalty to someone other than the Rams. And let's face facts: CSU isn't exactly a "must see" destination for high school players after three consecutive 3-9 seasons.
Still, a lack of stars does not mean there is a lack of incoming talent. I have watched numerous under-the-radar players -- walk-ons or others very lightly recruited -- become stars at CSU, and I thought I would share a few of those names, just to make you feel better.
Clark Haggans: A walk-on, he left CSU as the all-time leader in sacks and has played 10-plus years in the NFL.
Steve Bartalo: A walk-on who is CSU's all-time leading rusher.
Kelly Stouffer: A complete unknown in high school, nobody had heard of him when CSU signed him. He's the school's all-time leader in passing yards and was a first-round NFL draft pick.
Adrian Ross: Like Haggans, a walk-on defensive end who ended up playing several years in the NFL.
Greg Myers: He got exactly two offers coming out of Windsor High School, from CSU and Air Force. He was the only four-time, first-team all-conference player in WAC history, the Jim Thorpe Award winner and a recent addition to the Colorado Sports Hall of Fame.
John Howell: From tiny Mullen, Neb., Howell was a walk-on who was so good that he played in his first college game before becoming a star and NFL player.
Richie Hall: A 5-foot-7 cornerback from Thornton High School, he looked like your kid brother and played like Lester Hayes. He's in the Canadian Football League Hall of Fame.
Keli McGregor: A former walk-on tight end who ended up a two-time All-American tight end before becoming president of the Colorado Rockies.
So, climb down off that ledge and get a grip. Did McElwain sign a bunch of "stars"? No. Did he sign a stud or two who will become great players? Probably. Just don't tell Alabama ...